HomeGB EnergyCross-cuttingElectricityGasOil and upstreamHydrogenHeatNuclearCCUSInterconnectors

Governance scenario

CfD Strike Price Dispute

A CfD holder claims the reference price methodology undervalues their renewable output. Elexon and DESNZ must adjudicate a complex technical and commercial dispute.

Back to scenarios

This is a fictionalised teaching scenario grounded in real institutional roles, published reforms, and current public-source context.

Scenario player

Work through the decision path below. Each choice changes the route, the institutional trade-offs, and the metrics the scenario tracks.

CfD Strike Price Dispute

Step 1 of 2

Elexon

Generator disputes reference price

A solar farm under CfD challenges the Elexon reference price calculation. The generator argues that the reference price excludes recent capacity auction data that would show lower prices, understating their revenue need. Elexon says methodology is fixed and was transparent at award. The dispute amounts to GBP 2M per year over the CfD term.

What is at stake

  • -If you reopen methodology, you set precedent for many similar challenges.
  • -If you refuse, you may force a generator into financial distress.
  • -This affects confidence in CfD certainty for future rounds.

How do you respond to the challenge?

Current Metrics

Stakeholder Trust58
Affordability60
Operational Efficiency62
System Security70
Customer Protection62
Net Zero Progress68

Actors Involved

ElexonDESNZOfgemGenerators

Regulatory Context

Contracts for Difference (Capacity and Auctions) Regulations

Governance relationship map

View mode

Operating loop breadcrumb

Governance→Planning→Operations→Outcomes→Evidence

Current focus: Rules and accountability

Legend

Governance and policy

Rules, remits, and accountability

Planning and investment

Connections, queue progression, and delivery planning

System operations

Real-time balancing and network operation

Market and consumer outcomes

Prices, settlement, reliability, affordability

Evidence and learning

Telemetry, assurance, and continuous improvement

Glossary

  • Dispatch

    Real-time instructions to increase or reduce generation or demand so supply stays in balance.

  • Balancing

    The continuous process of matching electricity supply to demand while maintaining system frequency.

  • Constraint

    A technical limit in the network that restricts how power can flow under current conditions.

  • Industry code

    A formal rulebook that defines obligations and processes for specific market and network activities.

  • Connection agreement

    The formal agreement setting technical and milestone conditions for connecting a project to the network.

  • Settlement

    The process that turns metered and contractual positions into final market cashflow outcomes.

  • Conformance gate

    A quality checkpoint that verifies whether data or implementation meets agreed standards.

  • LTDS

    Long Term Development Statement publication requirements for distribution network data.

Guided tour

Step 1 of 8

Who sets the rules?

Start with governance: policy direction, regulatory oversight, licences, and code obligations.

Why it matters: Newcomers should first understand where authority sits before interpreting operational decisions.

Open Ofgem licence and code guidance

Preparing system graph…

Use this map to keep scenario decisions anchored to policy, coordination, operational delivery, and evidence feedback relationships.

Sources and methodology

How this page was assembled

Scenarios are designed as regulator-safe teaching runs. Institutional roles, programme context, and cited reform pathways stay grounded in current public sources, while event details and numbers inside the run remain fictionalised unless explicitly evidenced elsewhere. This scenario is framed against Contracts for Difference (Capacity and Auctions) Regulations.

Last reviewed 18 March 2026

Primary sources

Ransford's Notes